Never Really Finished

A hall with a console table, hydrangeas and a framed spaniel drawing

Tallmadge Ave · Bryn Mawr, PA

Never Really Finished

Eight rooms, ninety-four pieces, and a piece of advice from 1897 about how a house should be put together.

94 pieces · $25 to $875 · each one of a kind

In 1897 Charles Scribner’s Sons published a book about rooms by a New York woman who had not yet written a novel. Edith Wharton wrote The Decoration of Houses with Ogden Codman Jr., the Boston architect who had worked on her house in Newport. Most of it is an argument about proportion: doors, windows, where a chair should stand. The book went on to be called the manual every modern design book descends from.

Near the end, in a chapter on bric-à-brac, Wharton and Codman put the whole argument into one sentence. They admitted it asks for patience. A room furnished this way looks bare for a while, and some people can’t stand that.

“Buy each year one superior piece rather than a dozen of middling quality.”The Decoration of Houses, 1897

That is the deal, and it is the reason a good house is never finished. It is not meant to be. Each year it takes in one more thing that earned its place, and the rooms get better at being themselves.

What follows is laid out the way Wharton read a house, room by room: the hall, the library, the sideboard, the side table, the morning table, the kitchen (which she left out), the mantel, the drawing room. Eleven pieces to a room, one of them leading. Every piece is the only one we have. Any one of them would do for this year.

I · The Hall

A home is never really finished.

The first thing a guest sees and the last thing you check on the way out. A good mirror does most of the work here. The rest is what you set down beside it: the candlesticks, the little covered jar for keys, the case that came back from somewhere and never went up to the attic. And an empty frame on the wall, for whatever comes next.

The Library
From the film

II · The Library

It gathers stories.

An American country fair, painted in the late 1800s by a hand nobody wrote down: wagons, flags, a crowd with somewhere to be. Beside it, a spaniel and a pheasant painted by Patti McCarthy, who is still painting today. Then the things a desk collects over forty years.

The Sideboard
From the film

III · The Sideboard

The unexpected makes a home.

Every room worth remembering has one thing in it that should not work. A pair of tiger-striped urns on gilt mounts will do it on a mahogany sideboard. So will a doubles trophy somebody won and somebody else let go, or a harbor painted big enough to change the weather in the room.

The Side Table
From the film

IV · The Side Table

Small objects, big character.

“Eye and mind are limited in their receptivity to a certain number of simultaneous impressions.”Wharton & Codman, 1897

Wharton's rule for the small things, in the same chapter. So: few of them, each worth a second look. A terrier on a gilt Florentine board, seven inches by ten. A coral porcelain vase with a kingfisher in gold. A horse bank somebody fed pennies for years.

The Morning Table
From the film

V · The Morning Table

Everyday beauty, collected.

The good things should get used. Eight Copeland Spode saucers with hand-colored asters, for rings at night and a square of chocolate after lunch. A hotel water pitcher engraved for The Manor. Above the table, two girls and a bowl of berries, painted in the late nineteenth century and still deciding who gets the last one.

VI · The Kitchen

Collected pieces with a story.

Wharton and Codman gave the library its own chapter and the school-room its own chapter. They skipped the kitchen entirely. We wouldn't. A copper wash boiler that makes a good log bin now, an English ironstone pitcher made for a lodge, a yellowware bowl with blue bands. The pieces that did the work are the ones with the most to say.

The Mantel
From the film

VII · The Mantel

The beauty is in the details.

In winter the light finds the mantel first. A barn and silo in snow, signed and dated 1975, to hang above it. Silver candleholders on white stems. A pair of spaniels in the Staffordshire manner, the way English mantels have kept their dogs in pairs since Victoria.

The Drawing Room
From the film

VIII · The Drawing Room

The art of living with things that matter.

The room kept for company that ends up being the one you live in. One large painting, chosen the way Wharton told her readers to choose: Patti McCarthy's beach scene after Mary Cassatt, thirty-two inches square. Then a landscape in a black frame, a weathervane that has stopped pointing anywhere, and a mirror to carry the light across.

The rest of the year

Ninety-four pieces. Choose one.

Wharton’s advice still holds: one good thing a year, and the patience to live with the space around it. Each piece here is one of a kind. When it goes, it goes.

Every order is wrapped by hand in Bryn Mawr, and Christine signs every card. Shipping is free anywhere in the U.S.

Looking for something smaller? Gifts under $75.

More stories from Tallmadge Ave

Quotations from Edith Wharton and Ogden Codman Jr., The Decoration of Houses (Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1897), chapter XVI, “Bric-à-Brac.”